The 12 Worst Storylines of The O.C.

2

11. Anna-Summer-Seth Love Triangle

While Seth Cohen (Adam Brody) may be a cutie pie, there is no way this high school dork would have found himself being fought over by two beautiful women. The popular girl and socialite Summer Roberts (Rachel Bilson) would have started dating the captain of the football team instead of dressing up as Wonder Woman to compete with Anna (Samaire Armstrong) over socially awkward Seth.

Source: WB

3

10. Marissa and Johnny

We quickly gathered that Marissa (Mischa Barton) has issues from her shoplifting, her drug overdose in Mexico, and her strained relations with her parents; however, all of that didn’t help us understand why she developed feelings for mopey ol’ Johnny when she was still involved with Ryan.

© WB / Courtesy: Everett Collection

4

9. Julie Marries Caleb

Yes, she is a backstabbing gold digger and he is a rich aging playboy who pretends to be Hugh Hefner, but it all seems a little incestuous that Caleb Nichol (Alan Dale) marries a woman young who is old enough to be his daughter and coincidentally his daughter’s best friend. These two have no chemistry, and when producers realized their mistake, Caleb was killed off.

© WB / Courtesy: Everett Collection

5

8. Julie and the Girls Live in a Trailer Park

One would think that Julie Cooper (Melinda Clarke) the interim CEO of the Newport Group, would have enough financial savviness to avoid ending up in the poor house. It’s also unbelievable that she was able to hide her new digs from Newport socialites. Of course it doesn’t last long and they’re living the high life again when Julie becomes engaged to Summer’s dad.

6

7. Alex and Marissa

It’s a little farfetched that hot bartender Alex (Olivia Wilde) would lust after Seth Cohen (Adam Brody) in the first place. Seriously, how does this guy have so many attractive women pining over him? It’s a tough sell that after their breakup, Marissa Cooper (Mischa Barton) decides that she has the hots for Alex. This storyline was obviously a desperate grab for ratings.

© WB / Courtesy: Everett Collection

7

6. Marissa’s Death

Marissa Cooper (Mischa Barton) finally gets her life sorted out and graduates from high school. She is happy and planning to live with her dad for the year on a boat in Greece. Then she is killed when a drunken Kevin (Cam Gigandet) rams into her and Ryan’s car when they are headed to the airport. Why couldn’t the show’s creators just let Marissa be happy and go live on a boat in Greece? Hasn’t she been through enough?

Source: WB

8

5. Julie and Dr. Roberts

Apparently marrying her best friend’s dad wasn’t enough, and now Julie Cooper (Melinda Clarke) is after her daughter’s best friend’s dad, Dr. Neil Roberts (Michael Nouri). It makes no sense at all that after Julie and Neil break up, Neil moves to Seattle while leaving Julie to live in his mansion with his daughter Summer (Rachel Bilson).

Source: WB

9

4. Ryan’s Cage Fighting Career

Fans knew that Ryan Atwood (Ben McKenzie) was not going to take Marissa’s death well, but cage fighting and living in storage closet in a bar is a little extreme. Watching the love of your young teenage life die in your arms is definitely intense, but descending into the seedy underbelly of illegal bar fighting….really?

Michael Desmond / © WB / Courtesy: Everett Collection

10

3. Ryan the Hired Killer?

It’s well known that Ryan Atwood (Ben McKenzie) has anger issues, especially while coping with the death of his on and off again girlfriend Marissa Cooper (Mischa Barton). However, no one bought the whole storyline where Julie (Melinda Clarke) tries to have Kevin Volchok (Cam Gigandet) killed for driving into Ryan’s car and fatally injuring Marissa. All fans know, that beneath Ryan’s bad boy exterior, he is not a murderer and what mother would ruin a teenager’s life by pressuring him to kill someone?

Greg Schwartz / © WB / Courtesy: Everett Collection

11

2. The Alternate Universe

While hanging Chrismukkah decorations, Taylor Townsend (Autumn Reeser) and Ryan Atwood (Ben McKenzie) get knocked unconscious and have a dream where Ryan never came to Newport. This episode was painful to watch. It’s clear that writers are running out of ideas when they invent alternate universes.

Michael Yarish / © WB / Courtesy: Everett Collection

12

1. The Bullit

This character is pure caricature. Julie (Melinda Clarke) meets Gordon Bullit (Gary Grubbs) through NewMatch, a dating website she started with Kirsten (Kelly Rowan). In season four, she leaves him for Frank Atwood (Kevin Sorbo), Ryan’s dad, but in the series finale she is pregnant with Frank’s baby while walking down the aisle with the Bullit. And then she decides to ditch both of them? The whole triangle is underwhelming and overplayed. Why would any woman want to be Mrs. Bullit or the wife of a lying ex-con who abandons his child?

Michael Levine / © WB / Courtesy: Everett Collection

Michelle H